Single Payer Health Insurance Advocated for New York State (Buffalo Hearing)

December 13, 2014

City & Region

By Henry Davis | News Medical Reporter | Google+ on December 11, 2014 – 8:36 AM,

updated December 11, 2014 at 5:57 PM

Kirk A. Laubenstein, executive director of the Coalition for Economic Justice, testifies in favor of creating single-payer health insurance in New York at a hearing in Roswell Park Cancer Institute’s Hohn Auditorium. Assemblyman Richard N. Gottfried, D-Manhattan, sponsor of a bill to that effect, was presiding. John Hickey/Buffalo
One patient went overseas for an operation to avoid paying high out-of-pocket costs here.A single mother in a low-paying job worried that private health insurance will leave her financially strapped.
And a doctor described how the 18 health care providers where he practices need almost as many employees just to keep track of insurance paperwork.Those stories highlighted a hearing this week on creating single-payer health care in the state that advocates contend would solve those problems.


“The current system is not working, and we should not take a failure and make it a bigger failure,” said Dr. Jason M. Matuszak, a family physician who specializes in sports medicine at Excelsior Orthopaedics in Amherst.
Matuszak was one of about two dozen people who voiced support for New York Health, a bill sponsored by Assemblyman Richard N. Gottfried, D-Manhattan, during a hearing in Hohn Auditorium at Roswell Park Cancer Institute.
He’s conducting six hearings statewide, with plans to move the bill out of the Assembly’s Health Committee, of which he is chairman, and introduce it into the Assembly for a vote in the spring.
“Even people with coverage are finding obstacles to care and costs devastating to their finances,” Gottfried said.The bill, to no one’s surprise, is receiving intense criticism.The Business Council of New York State, which lobbies for private employers, has long been on record of opposing the proposal, calling its promise of universal, unlimited coverage “a mirage.”Gottfried is no stranger to trying get approved single-payer health care. The plan was originally introduced 23 years ago and passed the Assembly. It has not been brought to the Legislature for a vote since then.New York Health would fold in Medicare and other current government programs, and replace much of what the Affordable Care Act created. Funding would come from a payroll tax and a surcharge on higher income. Proponents offered examples of why single-payer is the better path to take.Matuszak cited a 27-year-old woman who teaches overseas and who suffered torn knee cartilage. Rather than pay high out-of-pocket costs here, she had her surgery in Spain, which operates a single-payer health system.“She did this despite top surgeons being here and the language barriers of getting care there,” he said. “She shouldn’t have to make that choice.”Single-payer health care is not socialized medicine, in which doctors and hospitals work for the government. Instead, the government becomes the primary payer of care, similar to Medicare, the federal health plan for those 65 and older.

To proponents of single-payer, the Affordable Care Act maintains an inefficient and complicated health system.

The United States spends almost twice as much as other developed nations on health care. But many of the key measurable results are, at best, the same, and problems persist with patient safety and poor access.

Administrative costs consume a large share of health spending and create bureaucratic hassles. The existence of multiple private insurers requires hospitals and doctors to administer many different contracts with different coverage and policies.

Matuszak noted that Excelsior needs 13 employees to handle the billing for its 18 health care providers.

“It compromises care,” he said.

Dr. Myron L. Glick, founder of the Jericho Road Community Health Center in Buffalo, described how for 20 years he has had a front-row seat to see the health system’s failure to take care of the poor and vulnerable.

He recalled a recent diabetic patient whose medication bill had reached $900 a month. She couldn’t afford it, even with existing programs for help.

“Access to health care is a basic human right,” he said.

Glick also criticized the amount of red tape, saying his practice deals with more than 100 insurance contracts for the 15 percent of his patients with private coverage.

Tasha Moore, a community health worker at the Matt Urban Hope Center, talked about how she will soon lose coverage through Medicaid, the health plan for the poor. Her private insurance will cost $120 a month, a price that’s financially overwhelming on her $12-an-hour salary. “It doesn’t help me. I can’t afford it,” she said.

The Buffalo Niagara Partnership, the regional chamber of commerce, issued a statement saying that the bill fails to consider the high costs associated with the proposed assessments for funding, or the positive economic impact that health plans have by providing tens of thousands of jobs, and paying property and payroll taxes.


Henry Davis

Copyright 1999 – 2014 – The Buffalo News copyright-protected material.





6 Responses to “Single Payer Health Insurance Advocated for New York State (Buffalo Hearing)”

  1. fifa 15 60k squad builder on May 22nd, 2015 9:39 am

    fifa 15 60k squad builder…

    Single Payer Health Insurance Advocated for New York State (Buffalo Hearing): Single Payer New York…

  2. farm madden 15 coins on June 25th, 2015 10:10 am

    Excellent blog post. I definitely love this site. Thanks!

  3. Another Opinion on July 17th, 2015 2:18 am

    So…we should adopt a radical, potentially risky new plan in the complex, high-population state of New York, even though a nearly identical plan was scrapped in the simple rural state of Vermont. (Do a google search for “Vermont single payer.”)
    Drug and medical device companies are required to perform clinical trials before subjecting the public to a new drug or device that will affect even tens of thousands of people. Wouldn’t it be good if our legislators could bear even a fraction of the responsibility of a drug or device company, and come up with a “clinical trial” of sorts, to see whether such a massive plan would, in reality, have a positive or a negative effect on the state of NY?
    Oh, wait, there was such a clinical trial…it was called the Affordable Care Act. Let me see how well that worked out for me, in relation to the promises:
    1. The President of the US promised me that, under the ACA, I would be able to (A) keep my insurance; (B) keep my doctor, and (C) enjoy lower health care costs.
    2. Instead, (A) I had to give up my insurance plan (which I had paid into for 8 years) for a worse one. (B) My best doctors did not participate in my new plan. (C) My health insurance premiums rose 60%.
    I guess, having been fooled in the very recent past, I’m just not all that inclined to believe yet another politician’s rosy but baseless promise about a health care utopia.

  4. excuses for a hickey on July 19th, 2015 6:35 am

    This site certainly has all of the info I wanted concerning this subject and didn’t
    know who to ask.

  5. Deidre on August 2nd, 2015 3:48 am

    Very good article. I absolutely appreciate this site.
    Stick with it!

  6. online video game renting on September 1st, 2015 2:38 am

    online video game renting

    Single Payer Health Insurance Advocated for New York State (Buffalo Hearing) : Single Payer New York